The Witcher 3 set a benchmark few RPGs have matched. Side quests that rival main stories, choices with real consequences, a continent that feels lived-in, and Geralt’s gravelly wit anchoring it all. If you’ve finished Blood and Wine and want more games that hit the same notes, you’re in the right place.
This list cuts straight to 15 alternatives that genuinely deliver narrative depth, open-world exploration, or fantasy RPG progression. No filler picks, no “kind of similar” stretches.
Quick Comparison: Top 5 Picks
| # | Game | Open World | Price | Platforms |
| 1 | Skyrim Anniversary | Yes | $49.99 | PC, PS, Xbox, Switch |
| 2 | Dragon Age: Inquisition | Partial | $39.99 | PC, PS, Xbox |
| 3 | Kingdom Come: Deliverance | Yes | $29.99 | PC, PS, Xbox, Switch |
| 4 | Elden Ring | Yes | $59.99 | PC, PS, Xbox |
| 5 | Red Dead Redemption 2 | Yes | $59.99 | PC, PS4, Xbox |
1. The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim
Why it’s similar
Massive open-world fantasy RPG with exploration, quests, and player freedom. The gold standard for open-world fantasy alongside The Witcher 3.
What makes it unique
Dragon Shouts replace traditional Witcher signs. Modding scene rivals every other RPG combined with 70,000+ available mods.
Key features
- Massive Skyrim open world
- Dragon Shouts system
- Active modding community
- 4 main factions
Price: $49.99 (Anniversary Edition) Platforms: PC, PS4, PS5, Xbox One, Xbox Series X/S, Switch
Where to Buy
Available on Green Man Gaming and Steam.
2. Dragon Age: Inquisition
Why it’s similar
Story-driven fantasy RPG with companions, choices, and world-building focus. The closest BioWare equivalent to CD Projekt Red’s storytelling.
What makes it unique
War Table strategic layer lets you direct Inquisition agents on side missions. Romance options and companion approval system add depth.
Key features
- Companion approval system
- War Table strategic layer
- Multiple romance options
- Three major expansion DLCs
Price: $39.99 (Game of the Year Edition) Platforms: PC, PS4, Xbox One
Where to Buy
Available on Green Man Gaming and Steam.
3. Kingdom Come: Deliverance
Why it’s similar
Immersive medieval world with narrative-driven quests and realism. Replaces Witcher’s fantasy with grounded historical accuracy.
What makes it unique
Historically accurate 15th century Bohemia setting. Realistic systems for combat, hygiene, hunger, sleep, and reputation. No fantasy magic or monsters.
Key features
- Historically accurate setting
- Skill-based combat
- Reputation and morality systems
- Realistic survival needs
Price: $29.99 (Royal Edition) Platforms: PC, PS4, Xbox One, Switch
Where to Buy
Available on Green Man Gaming and Steam.
4. Assassin’s Creed Odyssey
Why it’s similar
Large open world with RPG progression, dialogue choices, and exploration. Ancient Greek setting offers a Witcher-style sprawling adventure.
What makes it unique
Choose between Alexios or Kassandra as protagonist. Naval combat returns from Black Flag. Three story DLCs add 30+ hours.
Key features
- Ancient Greece open world
- Two protagonist options
- Naval combat
- Three story DLCs
Price: $59.99 (Ultimate Edition) Platforms: PC, PS4, Xbox One, Switch (Cloud)
Where to Buy
Available on Green Man Gaming and Steam.
5. Assassin’s Creed Valhalla
Why it’s similar
Open-world medieval setting with story progression and combat systems. Viking England parallels Witcher’s gritty fantasy tone.
What makes it unique
Settlement building feature lets you grow your home base across the campaign. Three massive expansions (Wrath of the Druids, Siege of Paris, Dawn of Ragnarök) extend playtime past 150 hours.
Key features
- 9th century England setting
- Settlement management
- Three story expansions
- Naval raiding mechanics
Price: $59.99 Platforms: PC, PS4, PS5, Xbox One, Xbox Series X/S
Where to Buy
Available on Green Man Gaming and Steam.
6. Elden Ring
Why it’s similar
Dark fantasy exploration and combat with open-ended world design. Witcher fans craving Soulslike depth should start here.
What makes it unique
FromSoftware Soulslike combat with massive open world structure. Shadow of the Erdtree DLC added 30+ hours of additional content.
Key features
- Lands Between open world
- Soulslike combat depth
- Shadow of the Erdtree DLC
- Multiple endings
Price: $59.99 Platforms: PC, PS4, PS5, Xbox One, Xbox Series X/S
Where to Buy
Available on Green Man Gaming and Steam.
7. Red Dead Redemption 2
Why it’s similar
Strong narrative and world immersion with side content and exploration depth. Different setting but matches Witcher’s storytelling polish.
What makes it unique
Western American setting replaces medieval Europe. Honor system tracks moral choices visibly affecting NPC reactions. Arthur Morgan’s story rivals Geralt’s emotional journey.
Key features
- Detailed American west setting
- Honor reputation system
- Hunting and survival mechanics
- Online multiplayer mode
Price: $59.99 Platforms: PC, PS4, Xbox One
Where to Buy
Available on Green Man Gaming and Steam.
8. Ghost of Tsushima
Why it’s similar
Cinematic storytelling plus open-world exploration with atmospheric world and combat. Wind-based navigation echoes Witcher senses.
What makes it unique
Four sword stances counter different enemy types. Wind navigation replaces traditional minimap waypoints. Iki Island DLC adds 20+ hours.
Key features
- Four sword stances
- Wind navigation
- Tsushima Island open world
- Iki Island expansion
Price: $59.99 Platforms: PC, PS4, PS5
Where to Buy
Available on Green Man Gaming and Steam.
9. GreedFall
Why it’s similar
Choice-driven RPG with factions, companion systems, and quests. Approachable size while preserving moral choice depth.
What makes it unique
17th century colonial era setting with magical natives and disease-ridden colonizers. Faction reputation determines available endings.
Key features
- 17th century alt-history setting
- Faction reputation system
- 5 companion characters
- Multiple endings
Price: $39.99 Platforms: PC, PS4, PS5, Xbox One, Xbox Series X/S
Where to Buy
Available on Green Man Gaming and Steam.
10. Dragon’s Dogma 2
Why it’s similar
Dynamic combat and open-world exploration with fantasy setting and progression systems. Pawn system adds party depth.
What makes it unique
Pawn cooperative system recruits AI companions created by other players. 10 vocations replace traditional classes with action-focused playstyles.
Key features
- Pawn cooperative system
- 10 vocations
- Real-time day/night impact
- Massive open world
Price: $69.99 Platforms: PC, PS5, Xbox Series X/S
Where to Buy
Available on Green Man Gaming and Steam.
11. Horizon Forbidden West
Why it’s similar
Story-focused open-world with RPG elements, exploration, and side activities. Aloy’s quest carries Witcher-style narrative weight.
What makes it unique
Robot dinosaur enemies require dismantling specific weak points. Burning Shores DLC adds significant story content.
Key features
- Robot dinosaur combat
- Burning Shores DLC included
- Post-apocalyptic California
- 100+ hour campaign
Price: $59.99 Platforms: PC, PS4, PS5
Where to Buy
Available on Green Man Gaming and Steam.
12. Fable Anniversary
Why it’s similar
Fantasy RPG with morality systems and character progression. Lighter British fantasy tone contrasts Witcher’s grimdark vibe.
What makes it unique
Good and evil choices visibly affect your character’s appearance over time. Marriage, property ownership, and family systems were ahead of their era.
Key features
- Morality-shaped appearance
- Marriage and family systems
- Property ownership
- Albion fantasy setting
Price: $34.99 Platforms: PC, Xbox 360 (backwards compatible)
Where to Buy
Available on Steam and Xbox Store.
13. Kingdoms of Amalur: Re-Reckoning
Why it’s similar
Fantasy RPG combat and quests with open-world progression systems. Side quests written by famed fantasy author R.A. Salvatore.
What makes it unique
Destiny system lets you respec your class identity on the fly. Hundreds of side quests written by R.A. Salvatore (Drizzt Do’Urden novels).
Key features
- Destiny class respec system
- 200+ hour campaign
- Action combat
- R.A. Salvatore narrative
Price: $39.99 (Re-Reckoning) Platforms: PC, PS4, Xbox One, Switch
Where to Buy
Available on Green Man Gaming and Steam.
14. Divinity II: Developer’s Cut
Why it’s similar
Fantasy RPG exploration and storytelling with quest-focused progression. Dragon transformation adds unique movement.
What makes it unique
Player character can transform into a dragon mid-game and fly across the open world. Includes the original Ego Draconis plus the Flames of Vengeance expansion.
Key features
- Dragon transformation
- Battle Tower base
- Comedy-tinged writing
- Pre-Original Sin Divinity setting
Price: $19.99 Platforms: PC
Where to Buy
Available on Steam and GOG.
15. Oblivion Remastered
Why it’s similar
Open-world fantasy RPG freedom with exploration-heavy gameplay. Cyrodiil offers Witcher-scale wilderness with classic Bethesda systems.
What makes it unique
Unreal Engine 5 visual overhaul of the 2006 classic. Gates of Oblivion still hit as memorable side content nearly 20 years later.
Key features
- UE5 visual remaster
- Cyrodiil open world
- 4 main factions
- Spell crafting system
Price: $49.99 Platforms: PC, PS5, Xbox Series X/S
Where to Buy
Available on Green Man Gaming and Steam.
Full Comparison Table
| # | Game | Open World | Price | Platforms |
| 1 | Skyrim Anniversary | Yes | $49.99 | PC, PS, Xbox, Switch |
| 2 | Dragon Age: Inquisition | Partial | $39.99 | PC, PS, Xbox |
| 3 | Kingdom Come: Deliverance | Yes | $29.99 | PC, PS4, Xbox, Switch |
| 4 | Assassin’s Creed Odyssey | Yes | $59.99 | PC, PS4, Xbox, Switch |
| 5 | Assassin’s Creed Valhalla | Yes | $59.99 | PC, PS, Xbox |
| 6 | Elden Ring | Yes | $59.99 | PC, PS, Xbox |
| 7 | Red Dead Redemption 2 | Yes | $59.99 | PC, PS4, Xbox |
| 8 | Ghost of Tsushima | Yes | $59.99 | PC, PS4, PS5 |
| 9 | GreedFall | Yes | $39.99 | PC, PS, Xbox |
| 10 | Dragon’s Dogma 2 | Yes | $69.99 | PC, PS5, Xbox |
| 11 | Horizon Forbidden West | Yes | $59.99 | PC, PS4, PS5 |
| 12 | Fable Anniversary | Yes | $34.99 | PC, Xbox 360 (BC) |
| 13 | Kingdoms of Amalur: Re-Reckoning | Yes | $39.99 | PC, PS4, Xbox, Switch |
| 14 | Divinity II: Developer’s Cut | Yes | $19.99 | PC |
| 15 | Oblivion Remastered | Yes | $49.99 | PC, PS5, Xbox |
Conclusion
The Witcher 3 fans have plenty of directions depending on what hooked them. Want more story-rich RPGs? Dragon Age Inquisition and GreedFall deliver choice-heavy adventures. Craving open-world freedom? Skyrim, Oblivion Remastered, and AC Odyssey provide endless exploration. Hungry for immersive realism? Kingdom Come Deliverance and Red Dead Redemption 2 set the gold standard.
The fantasy and open-world RPG genres have rarely had this many great options. Pick one based on whether you want medieval realism, Soulslike challenge, Norse mythology, or pure narrative depth. Every game on this list earned its place through real RPG craft, not just a “fantasy game” tag.
Read More Like This!
15 Games Like Oblivion Remastered You Need to Play in 2026
15 Games Like Cyberpunk 2077 You Need to Play in 2026
15 Games Like Borderlands 4 You Need to Play in 2026
15 Games Like Kingdom Come Deliverance 2 to Play in 2026
15 Games Like Coffee Talk Tokyo You Need to Play in 2026
15 Games Like Forza Horizon 6 You Need to Play in 2026
15 Games Like 007 First Light You Need to Play in 2026
15 Games Like Elden Ring Nightreign You Need to Play in 2026
15 Games Like Lies of P You Need to Play in 2026
15 Games Like Directive 8020 You Need to Play in 2026
15 Games Like Stellar Blade You Need to Play in 2026
15 Games Like ARC Raiders You Need to Play in 2026
15 Games Like Crimson Desert You Need to Play in 2026
15 Games Like Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 (2026 Guide)
15 Games Like PEAK You Need to Play in 2026