Lies of P took everyone by surprise. A Korean studio reimagining Pinocchio as a steampunk horror Souls-like had no right to land this hard, but Pinocchio’s journey through Krat delivered some of 2023’s best boss fights and a parry system that earned comparisons to FromSoftware’s best work. If you’ve wrapped up your Pinocchio arc and want more games that hit the same notes, you’re in the right place.
This list cuts straight to 15 alternatives that genuinely deliver Souls-like combat, precision parries, or dark fantasy atmosphere. No filler picks, no “kind of similar” stretches.
Quick Comparison: Top 5 Picks
| # | Game | Difficulty | Price | Platforms |
| 1 | Bloodborne | Hard | $19.99 | PS4 |
| 2 | Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice | Very Hard | $59.99 | PC, PS, Xbox |
| 3 | Dark Souls III | Hard | $59.99 | PC, PS, Xbox |
| 4 | Elden Ring | Hard | $59.99 | PC, PS, Xbox |
| 5 | Lords of the Fallen | Hard | $59.99 | PC, PS5, Xbox |
1. Bloodborne
Why it’s similar
Fast-paced Souls-like combat with dark gothic atmosphere and aggressive gameplay. Lies of P openly draws inspiration from Bloodborne’s Yharnam.
What makes it unique
Rally system rewards aggressive play by letting you regain lost HP through counter-attacks. Trick weapons transform mid-combo for adaptive moveset variety.
Key features
- Rally HP recovery system
- Trick weapon transformations
- Yharnam Victorian setting
- The Old Hunters DLC
Price: $19.99 Platforms: PS4
Where to Buy
Available on PlayStation Store.
2. Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice
Why it’s similar
Precision parry-focused combat with skill-based boss encounters. Lies of P’s perfect guard mechanic clearly draws from Sekiro’s deflect system.
What makes it unique
Posture system breaks enemy guard through aggressive parrying. Resurrection mechanic gives you one free revive per life.
Key features
- Posture-breaking parry combat
- One-time resurrection
- Sengoku Japan setting
- Prosthetic tool variety
Price: $59.99 Platforms: PC, PS4, Xbox One, Xbox Series X/S
Where to Buy
Available on Green Man Gaming and Steam.
3. Dark Souls III
Why it’s similar
Classic Souls progression and combat with challenging enemies and exploration. The most refined entry in the original trilogy.
What makes it unique
Faster combat pacing than Dark Souls 1 and 2. Ashes of Ariandel and The Ringed City DLCs add brutal optional content.
Key features
- Classic Souls level design
- Weapon arts system
- 2 expansive DLCs
- Refined combat pacing
Price: $59.99 Platforms: PC, PS4, Xbox One
Where to Buy
Available on Green Man Gaming and Steam.
4. Elden Ring
Why it’s similar
Souls-like combat with exploration freedom, build variety, and large-scale boss encounters. Lies of P fans craving open-world scale should start here.
What makes it unique
Massive Lands Between open world replaces traditional Souls level design. Shadow of the Erdtree DLC added 30+ hours of additional content.
Key features
- Lands Between open world
- Soulslike combat depth
- Shadow of the Erdtree DLC
- Multiple endings
Price: $59.99 Platforms: PC, PS4, PS5, Xbox One, Xbox Series X/S
Where to Buy
Available on Green Man Gaming and Steam.
5. Steelrising
Why it’s similar
Mechanical-themed Souls-like gameplay with puppet-inspired aesthetic. The closest visual cousin to Lies of P’s automaton designs.
What makes it unique
Set during an alternate French Revolution where automatons replace soldiers. Stylish anti-air combat with 4 different mechanical weapon trees.
Key features
- French Revolution setting
- Automaton enemy designs
- 4 weapon classes
- Cosmetic customization
Price: $49.99 Platforms: PC, PS5, Xbox Series X/S
Where to Buy
Available on Green Man Gaming and Steam.
6. Wo Long: Fallen Dynasty
Why it’s similar
Parry-heavy action combat with fast-paced enemy encounters. Team Ninja delivers more action-focused Souls combat.
What makes it unique
Spirit system mechanically encourages aggressive play through counter-attacks. Chinese Three Kingdoms setting with supernatural twists.
Key features
- Spirit aggression system
- Chinese Three Kingdoms setting
- Co-op with AI partners
- Five weapon classes
Price: $59.99 Platforms: PC, PS4, PS5, Xbox One, Xbox Series X/S
Where to Buy
Available on Green Man Gaming and Steam.
7. Nioh 2
Why it’s similar
Deep combat systems and builds with difficult enemy encounters and progression. Mastery-driven gameplay rewards Lies of P-trained reflexes.
What makes it unique
Burst Counter mechanic transforms certain enemy attacks into massive parry opportunities. Yokai form lets you transform into demons mid-combat.
Key features
- Burst Counter parry system
- Yokai form transformations
- 9 weapon types
- 3 expansion DLCs
Price: $49.99 (Complete Edition) Platforms: PC, PS4, PS5, Xbox Series X/S
Where to Buy
Available on Green Man Gaming and Steam.
8. Code Vein
Why it’s similar
Anime-inspired Souls combat with companion systems and customization. Post-apocalyptic vampire setting offers tonal contrast.
What makes it unique
Blood Code class system lets you swap entire builds instantly. AI companions accompany you throughout the campaign for accessible co-op feel.
Key features
- Blood Code class swapping
- AI companion partners
- Anime-style character creator
- Post-apocalyptic vampire setting
Price: $59.99 Platforms: PC, PS4, Xbox One
Where to Buy
Available on Green Man Gaming and Steam.
9. Mortal Shell
Why it’s similar
Dark atmosphere and methodical combat with Souls-style progression systems. Shorter campaign perfect for between-major-releases sessions.
What makes it unique
Harden mechanic turns your character to stone, blocking incoming damage. Shell system lets you possess different bodies with unique playstyles.
Key features
- Harden defense mechanic
- Four possessable Shells
- Compact 15-hour campaign
- Free Sister of Sin DLC
Price: $29.99 Platforms: PC, PS4, PS5, Xbox One, Xbox Series X/S
Where to Buy
Available on Green Man Gaming and Steam.
10. Lords of the Fallen
Why it’s similar
Modern Souls-like structure with challenging combat and world design. The 2023 reboot delivers Lies of P-level production polish.
What makes it unique
Umbral and Axiom dual-world system lets you traverse the same map across two dimensions. Soulflay lamp pulls enemies from one plane to another.
Key features
- Dual-world traversal
- Soulflay lamp system
- 9 starting classes
- Online co-op
Price: $59.99 Platforms: PC, PS5, Xbox Series X/S
Where to Buy
Available on Green Man Gaming and Steam.
11. Black Myth: Wukong
Why it’s similar
Precision action combat and boss fights with dark fantasy tone and cinematic presentation. Spectacle rivals the best FromSoftware bosses.
What makes it unique
Based on Journey to the West with 80+ enemies inspired by classical Chinese literature. Staff combat with transformation abilities defines the experience.
Key features
- Chinese mythology setting
- Staff combat with transformations
- 80+ unique boss encounters
- 4K visuals on PC
Price: $59.99 Platforms: PC, PS5, Xbox Series X/S
Where to Buy
Available on Green Man Gaming and Steam.
12. Thymesia
Why it’s similar
Fast combat with parry systems, gothic atmosphere, and difficult bosses. Plague-themed setting echoes Lies of P’s diseased Krat.
What makes it unique
Plague Weapon system steals enemy abilities and uses them against bosses. Shorter campaign (10-15 hours) ideal for focused Souls fans.
Key features
- Plague Weapon stealing
- Plague-themed setting
- Short focused campaign
- $30 entry price
Price: $29.99 Platforms: PC, PS5, Xbox Series X/S, Switch
Where to Buy
Available on Green Man Gaming and Steam.
13. Salt and Sanctuary
Why it’s similar
2D Souls-like gameplay with build variety and exploration. Side-scrolling perspective preserves Souls progression depth.
What makes it unique
Side-scrolling 2D perspective adds platforming layer absent from most Souls-likes. Salt and Sacrifice sequel adds more content if you finish the original.
Key features
- 2D Souls-like perspective
- 8 classes
- Co-op and PvP modes
- Brand creed system
Price: $17.99 Platforms: PC, PS4, PS5, Xbox One, Switch
Where to Buy
Available on Green Man Gaming and Steam.
14. Remnant 2
Why it’s similar
Souls-inspired difficulty with co-op shooting and boss-focused progression systems. Different combat style but identical mastery curve.
What makes it unique
Procedurally generated worlds mean every co-op playthrough offers different bosses, items, and paths. Archetype system creates deep build variety.
Key features
- 3-player co-op
- Procedural world generation
- Archetype-based builds
- Soulslike combat depth
Price: $49.99 Platforms: PC, PS5, Xbox Series X/S
Where to Buy
Available on Green Man Gaming and Steam.
15. Blasphemous
Why it’s similar
Dark religious aesthetic plus difficult combat and exploration-focused progression. Spanish folklore-inspired horror tone matches Lies of P’s dread.
What makes it unique
Pixel art Metroidvania with religious horror themes. Heavy choice consequences and multiple endings reward repeated playthroughs.
Key features
- Pixel art Metroidvania
- Religious horror themes
- 3 endings
- Free DLC content
Price: $24.99 Platforms: PC, PS4, PS5, Xbox One, Xbox Series X/S, Switch
Where to Buy
Available on Green Man Gaming and Steam.
Full Comparison Table
| # | Game | Difficulty | Price | Platforms |
| 1 | Bloodborne | Hard | $19.99 | PS4 |
| 2 | Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice | Very Hard | $59.99 | PC, PS, Xbox |
| 3 | Dark Souls III | Hard | $59.99 | PC, PS, Xbox |
| 4 | Elden Ring | Hard | $59.99 | PC, PS, Xbox |
| 5 | Steelrising | Hard | $49.99 | PC, PS5, Xbox |
| 6 | Wo Long: Fallen Dynasty | Medium | $59.99 | PC, PS, Xbox |
| 7 | Nioh 2 | Hard | $49.99 | PC, PS, Xbox |
| 8 | Code Vein | Medium | $59.99 | PC, PS4, Xbox One |
| 9 | Mortal Shell | Medium | $29.99 | PC, PS, Xbox |
| 10 | Lords of the Fallen | Hard | $59.99 | PC, PS5, Xbox |
| 11 | Black Myth: Wukong | Hard | $59.99 | PC, PS5, Xbox |
| 12 | Thymesia | Medium | $29.99 | PC, PS5, Xbox, Switch |
| 13 | Salt and Sanctuary | Medium | $17.99 | PC, PS, Xbox, Switch |
| 14 | Remnant 2 | Medium | $49.99 | PC, PS5, Xbox |
| 15 | Blasphemous | Medium | $24.99 | PC, PS, Xbox, Switch |
Conclusion
Lies of P fans have plenty of directions depending on what hooked them. Want pure FromSoftware? Bloodborne, Sekiro, Dark Souls III, and Elden Ring are the obvious starting points. Craving modern Souls-likes? Lords of the Fallen, Steelrising, and Black Myth Wukong deliver Lies of P-level polish. Hungry for atmospheric variety? Blasphemous and Salt and Sanctuary expand the genre into 2D.
The Souls-like genre has never been healthier. Pick one based on whether you want FromSoftware classics, modern parry precision, or atmospheric exploration. Every game on this list earned its spot through real Souls-like credentials, not just a “hard game” tag.
Read More Like This!
15 Games Like Elden Ring Nightreign You Need to Play in 2026
15 Games Like Dark Souls You Need to Play in 2026
15 Games Like Elden Ring You Need to Play in 2026
15 Games Like Borderlands 4 You Need to Play in 2026
15 Games Like Black Myth: Wukong You Need to Play in 2026
15 Games Like Stellar Blade You Need to Play in 2026
15 Games Like Directive 8020 You Need to Play in 2026
15 Games Like Kingdom Come Deliverance 2 to Play in 2026
15 Games Like Forza Horizon 6 You Need to Play in 2026
15 Games Like ARC Raiders You Need to Play in 2026
15 Games Like 007 First Light You Need to Play in 2026
15 Games Like Coffee Talk Tokyo You Need to Play in 2026
15 Games Like Oblivion Remastered You Need to Play in 2026
15 Games Like Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 (2026 Guide)
15 Games Like Battlefield 6 You Need to Play in 2026